Shri Satyanarain Dudhani Vs. Uday Kumar Singh & Ors.
EmailAppeal: Civil Appeal No.4337 (NCE) of 1988
Petitioner: Shri Satyanarain Dudhani
Respondent: Uday Kumar Singh & Ors.
Apeal: Civil Appeal No.4337 (NCE) of 1988
Judges: M.H. KANIA & KULDIP SINGH, JJ.
Date of Judgment: Jan 23, 1990
Appearances:
1. M/s. S.V. Deshpandey and Ranjan Dwivedi, Advocates for the Parties.
Head Note:
REPRESENTATION OF PEOPLE ACT, 1951:
Judgment of the High Court declaring the election of the appellant as void set aside – Reasons to be recorded later.
JUDGEMENT:
KULDIP SINGH, J.:
After hearing the arguments we reserved judgment in this election appeal. The Election Commission has announced fresh elections to the Bihar Legislative Assembly. There is thus an urgency to announce the judgment. For the reasons to be recorded later on we allow the appeal with costs and set aside the order of the High Court dated March 30, 1988 ordering recount and allowing inspection of ballot papers. As a consequence the order of the High Court dated December 6, 1988 declaring the election of the appellant to Tundi assembly constituency as void and declaring respondent Uday Kumar Singh as duly elected is also set aside. The election petition filed by Shri Uday Kumar Singh challenging the election of the appellant Shri Satyanarain Dudhani is dismissed with costs. We quantify the costs as Rs.7000/-.
After hearing the arguments we reserved judgment in this election appeal. The Election Commission has announced fresh elections to the Bihar Legislative Assembly. There is thus an urgency to announce the judgment. For the reasons to be recorded later on we allow the appeal with costs and set aside the order of the High Court dated March 30, 1988 ordering recount and allowing inspection of ballot papers. As a consequence the order of the High Court dated December 6, 1988 declaring the election of the appellant to Tundi assembly constituency as void and declaring respondent Uday Kumar Singh as duly elected is also set aside. The election petition filed by Shri Uday Kumar Singh challenging the election of the appellant Shri Satyanarain Dudhani is dismissed with costs. We quantify the costs as Rs.7000/-.
