N. Suresh Nathan & Anr. Vs. Union of India & Ors.
EmailAppeal: Civil Appeal No.4542 of 1991
Petitioner: N. Suresh Nathan & Anr.
Respondent: Union of India & Ors.
Apeal: Civil Appeal No.4542 of 1991
Judges: LALIT MOHAN SHARMA, J.S. VERMA & S.C. AGRAWAL, JJ.
Date of Judgment: Nov 22, 1991
Head Note:
SERVICE AND LABOUR LAW
Recruitment Rules for the Post of Asst. Engineer in P.W.D.
Rules 7 and 11- Appointment by promotion – Qualification in the case of Diploma-holder Junior Engineer – Three years’ service experience whether includes the period prior to obtaining the Degree? – Held no – The service in the grade as a Diploma-holder prior to obtaining the Degree cannot be counted as service in the grade with a Degree for the purpose of three years’ service as a Degree-holder. (Para 5)
JUDGEMENT:
J.S. VERMA, J. :
1. The Recruitment Rules for the Post of Assistant Engineer in the Public Works Department, Pondicherry, prescribe the educational and other qualifications for appointment by direct recruitment and promotion. For direct recruits, the qualification prescribed is a Degree in Civil Engineering of a recognised University or Diploma in Civil Engineering from a recognised institution with three years’ professional experience. For appointment by promotion of Section Officers now called Junior Engineers, the qualification prescribed is as under :-
“1. Section Officers possessing a recognised Degree in Civil Engineering or equivalent with three years’ service in the grade failing which Section Officers holding Diploma in Civil Engineering with six years’ service in the grade – 50%.
2. Section Officers possessing a recognised Diploma in Civil Engineering with six years’ service in the grade – 50%.”
2. The dispute in the present case is whether a Diploma-holder Junior Engineer who obtains a Degree while in service becomes eligible for appointment as Assistant Engineer by promotion on completion of three years’ service including therein the period of service prior to obtaining the Degree or the three years’ service as a Degree-holder for this purpose is to be reckoned from the date he obtains the Degree. The Diploma-holders contend that they are entitled to include the earlier period and would be eligible for promotion in this category on obtaining the Degree if the total period of service is three years inclusive of the earlier period. The Degree-holders contest this position and contend to the contrary. According to the Degree-holders, these are two distinct categories. In the first category are Degree-holders with three years’ service in the grade as Degree-holders, the period of three years being subsequent to the date of obtaining the Degree as in the case of the Junior Engineers who join the service with a Degree; and the other category is of Diploma-holders with six years’ experience.
3. The Diploma-holders went to the Central Administrative Tribunal with this contention and the Tribunal has upheld their claim and directed as under :
“In the light of the above, we hold that the applicants are entitled to the relief asked for and accordingly we direct the respondents to consider them for promotion to the post of Assistant Engineer on par with the other Degree-holding Junior Engineers, taking due note of their total length of service rendered in the grade of Junior Engineer. Such a consideration should be along side other Junior Engineers who might have acquired the necessary Degree qualification earlier than the applicants, while holding the post of Junior Engineer. For this purpose, the first three respondents shall take necessary action to convene a review D.P.C. and pass orders on the basis of the recommendations of that D.P.C. within a period of three months from the date of receipt of a copy of this order.
The application is allowed as above.”
Hence this petition for grant of special leave by the Degree-holders. Leave is granted.
1. The Recruitment Rules for the Post of Assistant Engineer in the Public Works Department, Pondicherry, prescribe the educational and other qualifications for appointment by direct recruitment and promotion. For direct recruits, the qualification prescribed is a Degree in Civil Engineering of a recognised University or Diploma in Civil Engineering from a recognised institution with three years’ professional experience. For appointment by promotion of Section Officers now called Junior Engineers, the qualification prescribed is as under :-
“1. Section Officers possessing a recognised Degree in Civil Engineering or equivalent with three years’ service in the grade failing which Section Officers holding Diploma in Civil Engineering with six years’ service in the grade – 50%.
2. Section Officers possessing a recognised Diploma in Civil Engineering with six years’ service in the grade – 50%.”
2. The dispute in the present case is whether a Diploma-holder Junior Engineer who obtains a Degree while in service becomes eligible for appointment as Assistant Engineer by promotion on completion of three years’ service including therein the period of service prior to obtaining the Degree or the three years’ service as a Degree-holder for this purpose is to be reckoned from the date he obtains the Degree. The Diploma-holders contend that they are entitled to include the earlier period and would be eligible for promotion in this category on obtaining the Degree if the total period of service is three years inclusive of the earlier period. The Degree-holders contest this position and contend to the contrary. According to the Degree-holders, these are two distinct categories. In the first category are Degree-holders with three years’ service in the grade as Degree-holders, the period of three years being subsequent to the date of obtaining the Degree as in the case of the Junior Engineers who join the service with a Degree; and the other category is of Diploma-holders with six years’ experience.
3. The Diploma-holders went to the Central Administrative Tribunal with this contention and the Tribunal has upheld their claim and directed as under :
“In the light of the above, we hold that the applicants are entitled to the relief asked for and accordingly we direct the respondents to consider them for promotion to the post of Assistant Engineer on par with the other Degree-holding Junior Engineers, taking due note of their total length of service rendered in the grade of Junior Engineer. Such a consideration should be along side other Junior Engineers who might have acquired the necessary Degree qualification earlier than the applicants, while holding the post of Junior Engineer. For this purpose, the first three respondents shall take necessary action to convene a review D.P.C. and pass orders on the basis of the recommendations of that D.P.C. within a period of three months from the date of receipt of a copy of this order.
The application is allowed as above.”
Hence this petition for grant of special leave by the Degree-holders. Leave is granted.
